Preprint / Version 2

THE SILENT CAPTURE – Closure Capture, Opacity, and the Limits of Criminal Governance Theory: A Hypothesis from the Brazilian Case

##article.authors##

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.1590/SciELOPreprints.16824

Keywords:

Criminal Governance, Closure Capture, Observational Equivalence, Process Tracing, Institutional Infiltration

Abstract

This article proposes the concept of closure capture to examine an institutional vulnerability associated with the limited independent verifiability of decisions made by terminal review bodies. It begins with the problem of observational equivalence between decisions reached under conditions of institutional integrity and decisions potentially influenced by external interests, when oversight and scrutiny mechanisms are insufficient to distinguish between them. Using a theoretical-conceptual approach and exploratory plausibility probes, the study examines episodes related to the Munditia, Ethos, and Scream Fake operations, as well as the Banco Master case, across distinct institutional contexts. The comparison does not presuppose links among the cases and does not constitute evidence of a common causal chain. The article argues that the concentration of decision-making authority, procedural opacity, and limitations on independent review may reduce the capacity for external verification, without, in themselves, establishing that capture has occurred. The concept is presented as an analytical hypothesis to be subjected to comparative empirical testing, with explicit falsification criteria and attention to alternative explanations. The article concludes that institutional verifiability may contribute to the analysis of vulnerabilities in democratic accountability, provided that it is treated as a graded and empirically investigable dimension rather than as presumptive evidence of corruption or capture.

Keywords: Criminal Governance; Closure Capture; Observational Equivalence; Institutional Verifiability; Case Studies.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Submitted

07/07/2026

Posted

08/07/2026 — Updated on 10/19/2026

Versions

How to Cite

THE SILENT CAPTURE – Closure Capture, Opacity, and the Limits of Criminal Governance Theory: A Hypothesis from the Brazilian Case. (2026). In SciELO Preprints. https://doi.org/10.1590/SciELOPreprints.16824 (Original work published 2026)

Section

Applied Social Sciences

Plaudit

Version justification

Esta versão revisada incorpora correções textuais, bibliográficas e de formatação identificadas após a submissão inicial, com o objetivo de aprimorar a clareza, a consistência interna e a apresentação do manuscrito. Foram ajustadas a organização das notas de rodapé, a correspondência entre citações e referências, a delimitação metodológica dos estudos de caso e a explicitação do caráter hipotético e exploratório do conceito de captura de fecho. Também foram aperfeiçoadas as transições entre os casos analisados, de modo a esclarecer que a comparação tem finalidade analítica e heurística, sem pressupor vínculos causais entre os episódios ou afirmar a ocorrência comprovada de captura institucional. As alterações buscam tornar o argumento mais preciso, transparente e verificável, preservando a proposta teórica central do trabalho.

Data statement

  • The research data is contained in the manuscript